S/MIME Management and Automation: Challenges & solutions

S/MIME Management and Automation: Challenges & solutions
05 Feb ‘25

The Challenges of Enterprise-Wide S/MIME Implementation and How KeyTalk Solves Them

S/MIME certificates play a crucial role in securing email communication, ensuring authenticity and encryption for sensitive correspondence. However, implementing S/MIME across an entire company is far from straightforward. Many organizations struggle with challenges such as mass certificate creation, deployment, configuration, and management. Additionally, dealing with shared mailboxes and multi-device accessibility of encrypted emails further complicates the process.

 

The Complexity of Mass Creating S/MIME Certificates

For each email account, whether it belongs to an individual user or a shared mailbox, organizations must generate a Certificate Signing Request (CSR) and securely store the corresponding private key. The CSR then needs to be signed by a trusted Certificate Authority (CA), after which the signed certificate must be merged with its private key to create an installable S/MIME certificate in PFX or PEM format.

While IT departments may have user data readily available in EntraID or Active Directory (AD), executing this process manually is both time-consuming and error-prone. KeyTalk streamlines this process by integrating directly with EntraID or AD, allowing for automatic mass CSR generation. By connecting to various private and public CAs, KeyTalk ensures fast and effective CSR processing while pairing the certificate with its corresponding private key.

 

Securely Deploying and Installing S/MIME Certificates on End-User Devices

Once S/MIME certificates are generated, they need to be securely distributed. A common but highly insecure practice is sending the password-protected PFX via email and sharing the password through the same channel. This approach not only poses a security risk but also creates an administrative burden for end users who must manually install the certificates, often resulting in increased support requests.

KeyTalk eliminates these security and usability concerns by employing a dedicated KeyTalk agent that utilizes existing user credentials (such as AD usernames/passwords or Kerberos tokens) to fetch and install S/MIME PFX files automatically. Alternatively, KeyTalk integrates with enterprise Mobile Device Management (MDM) solutions like Intune or MobileIron, enabling seamless mass deployment and installation.

 

Automated Mail Client Configuration for S/MIME Usage

Even after successful certificate installation, mail clients must be correctly configured to enable digital signing and encryption. Microsoft Outlook, for example, requires navigating through multiple menus, which can confuse users—especially when configuring multiple S/MIME certificates for personal and shared mailboxes within the same client.

KeyTalk simplifies this step by automatically configuring Outlook to recognize the installed certificates as long as the corresponding mailbox exists. Furthermore, integration with MDM solutions allows KeyTalk to configure native mail clients, while direct interfacing with Exchange Online and EntraID ensures that S/MIME certificates are published in the Global Address List (GAL) for easy internal encryption.

 

Managing the Full Lifecycle of S/MIME Certificates

S/MIME certificate deployment is only the beginning; ongoing management presents another major challenge. Employees leave companies, get married (necessitating email address changes), upgrade devices, and require new certificates upon domain name changes or mergers. Additionally, with a maximum validity of one year, certificates must be renewed regularly.

KeyTalk addresses this ongoing burden by tracking renewals and automating certificate reissuance before expiry, ensuring seamless continuity without manual intervention from IT teams.

 

The Challenges of Shared Mailboxes and S/MIME

Shared mailboxes introduce additional complexity when implementing S/MIME. Unlike individual users, shared mailboxes are accessed by multiple employees, making certificate ownership and key management more complicated. Traditionally, each user accessing a shared mailbox would require access to the associated S/MIME private key, which raises security concerns and administrative overhead.

KeyTalk simplifies S/MIME certificate management for shared mailboxes by allowing controlled access through its secure distribution mechanisms. By integrating with EntraID or AD, KeyTalk ensures that only authorized users can obtain and use the shared mailbox certificate while maintaining security compliance. This approach eliminates the need for manual key distribution while preserving the integrity of encrypted email communications.

 

Ensuring Multi-Device Accessibility and Key Rollover

A critical challenge in S/MIME deployment is ensuring accessibility across multiple devices. Users frequently switch between desktops, laptops, and mobile devices, requiring seamless access to their S/MIME certificates. Moreover, as certificates and keys are periodically renewed, users must still be able to decrypt emails that were encrypted with previous certificates.

KeyTalk ensures multi-device accessibility and smooth key rollover by maintaining a secure repository of historical certificates and private keys. This allows users to continue decrypting older emails even after certificate updates. KeyTalk’s intelligent certificate management ensures that as devices change or certificates expire, users can still retrieve and use their previous keys without disruption.

 

Conclusion

Deploying S/MIME across an organization is an essential but complex endeavor. From mass certificate creation to deployment, configuration, and ongoing management, organizations face numerous challenges. KeyTalk’s automated solutions eliminate these obstacles by integrating seamlessly with existing identity management systems, CAs, MDMs, and mail clients. Whether handling individual accounts, shared mailboxes, or multi-device accessibility, KeyTalk ensures secure, efficient, and hassle-free S/MIME implementation, enabling organizations to focus on their core operations without compromising email security.

 

 

Interested in how KeyTalk can help your organization tackle the challenges and solutions surrounding certificate management and automation for mobile devices? Contact us by filling out the form below and discover how we can assist you in optimizing your certificate management.

 

The KeyTalk Team

Contact us

if you are interested in what we can do for your organisation with PKI / CLM management after reading our blog, please fill in the contact form below and we will contact you right away.